Filmsite Movie Review
Play Misty For Me (1971)
Pages: (1)

Play Misty For Me (1971), Clint Eastwood's first film as star and director, is a suspenseful, thrilling film of psychotic sexual obsession (" invitation to terror..."), advertised with the tagline:

"The scream you hear may be your own!"

It was one of the first female stalker films, an early precursor to Fatal Attraction (1987).

The Story

In the town of Carmel, California, cool-talking, all-night DJ, Dave Garver (Clint Eastwood) receives regular requests to play "Misty", the Erroll Garner classic, from a seductive listener/fan Evelyn Draper (Jessica Walter). When he first meets her in a local pickup bar, The Sardine Factory, and they have a one-night stand, he is not aware that she is the mysterious voice who always asked:

Play 'Misty' for me.

He believes it is just that - a one-night encounter. However, she often drops in on him unexpectedly and uninvited, causing him problems, and he becomes increasingly terrified and upset by her. In one telling conversation in which she reveals her borderline personality problems, she tells him that she thought they have a 'relationship' - but he vehemently denies it:

Garver: I just don't know what to say to you.
Evelyn: I'm sorry I mistrusted you. I should've known you'd never do anything to spoil it.
Garver: To spoil what?
Evelyn: What we have between us.
Garver: We don't have a god-damn thing between us. Now how many ways am I gonna have to say this to you?
Evelyn: I don't care how many ways you have to say it, it's not true!
Garver: What do I have to do to convince you?
Evelyn: It's not true! It's not.

Evelyn becomes angry and jealous and feels abandoned. She attempts suicide by slitting her wrists. She knifes his cleaning woman and destroys his possessions, and as a result, is put away in a mental institution.

When she is later released, Evelyn resumes her nightly requests for Misty. She promises Dave that she is cured, but becomes especially crazed when he resumes his relationship with blonde ex-girlfriend Tobie Williams (Donna Mills).

In a horrifying scene, Garver is awakened in the middle of the night in his bedroom to the sounds of 'Misty' being played. Evelyn, now a possessive, obsessive, murderous psychotic stalker, appears above him with a butcher knife ready to stab him - and she stabs his pillow. He evades her, saving his life, but she escapes.

As the tension builds, he fears for his ex-girlfriend's life and in a chilling discovery, realizes that Tobie's recently acquired roommate is the crazed Evelyn. A police sergeant, McCallum (John Larch), sent to protect her, is stabbed to death with a pair of scissors. Tobie is tied up and terrorized in the dark house as bait to lure Dave inside. Evelyn threatens Tobie with a pair of scissors:

Careful, I might put your eye out. I'll bet David loves your eyes. And your hair. Does he run his fingers through your hair? Have to get you all nice for David. For David. I hope he likes what he sees when he walks in here, because that's what he's taking to Hell with him.

During a truly scary, knife-wielding confrontation, Dave finds Tobie bound and gagged on a bed. He is again attacked and badly wounded by Evelyn. After being slashed many times, he punches her in the jaw, sending her through the balcony window to her death, down a rocky cliff and into the ocean below.

In an ironic ending, while Dave is comforting Tobie, the radio is heard in the background playing a tape of Dave honoring Evelyn's request to play Misty:

And now here's a pretty one for lonely lovers on a cool, cool night. It's the great Erroll Garner classic, Misty. And this one is especially for Evelyn.